Factor X · Volumes 1 to 5 and the comic

What Factor X has reached

Five volumes, two publishers, one comic. First what the counts show: five charts, hover or tap the marks, open the tables for the numbers. Then what the counts miss, bounded with levers you can move. This is the conservative version: no lever goes beyond the central estimate, and the method is written out at the end.

Observed
21 October 2026; Routledge reports read 29 October 2026
Volumes
1 to 3 Springer, 2013 to 2018 · 4 and 5 Routledge, open access, 2020 and 2022

How to quote this page. The counts as they stand, with their date. The estimates only as corridors, with their evidence grade and the assumption behind them. The comic’s measured core is 26,823 visitors in 2022; everything above it is bounded, not counted.

Reach so far

What the five volumes and the Volume 5 comic have reached. The publishers’ counts are views and downloads, not readers; Crossref is the conservative floor for citations.

Five volumes, two publishers

Open access changed the pace. Per year online, Volume 5 is read about six times as often as Volume 3 and cited about twice as often.

Springer, 2013 to 2018Routledge, open access, 2020 and 2022

Views and downloads, as the publisher counts them

Crossref citation events, chapters and book record

SpringerLink counts “accesses”, Routledge “uses”: both are chapter views and downloads, not readers. Crossref is the conservative floor; Google Scholar and Scopus could not be read. Observed 21 October 2026.

Show as table
VolumePublisher, yearYears onlineViews and downloadsCrossref events (chapters + book)Chapters cited
1 Re-sourceSpringer 201313.519,00026 (20 + 6)9 of 18
2 Policy, Strategies and InstrumentsSpringer 201412.514,00017 (14 + 3)6 of 17
3 Challenges, Implementation Strategies and ExamplesSpringer 20179.151,00099 (86 + 13)22 of 31
4 The Nexus ApproachesRoutledge 20205.958,00011 (10 + 1)6 of 29
5 The Impossibilities of the Circular EconomyRoutledge 20223.9137,00085 (70 + 15)16 of 26

The chapters do the travelling

Citations cluster in a few chapters per volume, and the leaders carry a claim in their title.

Crossref citations per chapter DOI, 21 October 2026; each square is one chapter, filled when cited at least once. Semantic Scholar lists run longer (Antikainen et al. 25, Kabbe 11) because they include theses and reports.

Independent readers per year, Routledge volumes

Volume 5 peaked in its first full year and still outreads Volume 4’s best year. Both decline without new attention.

Vol 5, The Impossibilities of the Circular EconomyVol 4, The Nexus Approachesdashed: 2026 to October

Uses by readers who opened the book outside an institution (“country unknown” in Routledge’s report), 81 to 82 percent of all uses. Top identified countries: Vol 5 Germany 4,908, Netherlands 3,425, UK 2,144, US 1,882; Vol 4 Germany 1,967, Indonesia 1,345, UK 972, US 730.

Show as table
YearVol 4Vol 5
20203,307
202111,107
20229,80031,804
20236,14239,417
20246,87919,376
20254,39713,933
2026 to October5,5547,858
All uses, all countries58,000137,000

How the comic travelled

One launch-week post made 2022. Permissioned reuse and the Italian translation gave it a second life in 2023; since then, little.

Shares on LinkedInReuse and mediaTranslationsCitationssize: visible engagement numbers

Search engines index only part of LinkedIn, so the shares are a floor. My own posts (August 2022, March 2023) are behind LinkedIn’s sign-up wall and show no metrics to outside readers. Individuals other than the launch post’s author and the illustrator are described by role, not named.

Show as list
DateWhatVisible numbers

Six languages, one distribution chain

A translation travels only when a partner carries it. Italian had two carriers; Spanish and Chinese had none.

English360dialogues.com, businessmodellab.nl, SlideShare, the illustrator’s site. Shares, guides, blogs, a podcast, a video, one book reference.
ItalianTransition Italia. Carried by ANCI Emilia-Romagna’s newsletter and economiacircolare.com, covered by envi.info.
FrenchRethink & React, titled “Les limites”. One LinkedIn share.
GermanAG Rohstoffe, Austria. On its own site only; no share found.
SpanishRethink & React, titled “Los límites”. On businessmodellab.nl only.
ChineseTranslator uncredited. Chinese platforms were not searchable; no trace on the open web.
DutchThe series page says seven languages. No Dutch file exists online.

Dots: places off the hosting pages where the version was found. The comic page shows three of the six versions; German, French and Spanish sit only on Saxion’s platform, which the page does not link.

Beyond the counts

What the counts miss, bounded rather than guessed. Every figure carries one of three evidence grades, and the grades never mix inside one number. The sliders run from the conservative value to the central estimate and no further; the full corridors, including the high cases, are in the written report.

M measured: a publisher dashboard, an API or a public page on a stated date FX inferred from Factor X’s own patterns: country and year rows, the Italian carrier chain, the LinkedIn posts search engines index B benchmarked from an outside study; vendor studies marked as such

From uses to people

A Routledge use is one chapter opened or downloaded on the publisher’s site, bot-filtered. A whole-book download of Volume 5 can register 26 uses, and the same reader counts again on every visit. Two divisions turn uses into people.

Presets
VolumeUses MReading sessionsDistinct peopleUses per citation FX

Counts: Routledge Author View reports (read 29 October 2026), SpringerLink book pages and Crossref (21 October 2026). The paywalled Springer volumes run 515 to 820 accesses per citation; open access raises that ratio about 4 to 7 times (publisher studies 2017 to 2024), so 1,600 and 5,300 for the Routledge volumes is the signature of an open-access edited volume, not of unread downloads. 82 percent of Routledge uses come from networks no institution can be attributed to.

Lectures, workshops and meetings

Nothing in this channel is measured, for Factor X or for anyone else. Five factors stand between the people who opened the comic and the people who saw it in a room. The lever is the adoption rate, and no study has measured it for a comparable resource.

Presets
Adopters: people who showed it to a group at least oncethe lever; a permission-request count is a floor, a five-question survey replaces it
Learners and meeting participants

Report corridor 3,600 / 75,600 / 260,000; this page stops at the central value. The open-access books travel by a different route, through institutions: Routledge identified 422 institutions with usage of Volume 5 and 342 of Volume 4; at 5 to 10 percent course use, 25 to 40 students per course and 1 to 1.5 runs that is 500 to 2,500 students for Volume 5 and 400 to 2,000 for Volume 4.

Five translations, no download data

A translation’s reach is its carriers’ audience, not its file count. Italian had two carriers and is findable; German, French and Spanish sit on an unlinked university platform; Chinese has no trace. The little-used case is a real possibility, not a formality.

Case
Readers of the five translations, cumulative
Ceiling if all five were carried and integrated B12,300 a yearWikipedia views by language relative to English, 2015 to 2025, summed to 0.46; translations take a third to 40 percent of total use at MIT OpenCourseWare and TED

Grades: Italian B, carriers’ audience at 20 to 60 percent of the 1,600 Italian ceiling in the launch year, tail of 10 to 30 percent a year; German and French B, an NGO or consultancy page at 200 to 1,000 visitors over three years with 20 to 50 percent downloading, plus the orphan floor; Spanish B, orphan floor only (96.55 percent of pages get no Google traffic, Ahrefs 2023, vendor); Chinese not estimable. FX prior: Germany is the largest identified country for both books, Italy fifth and Spain seventh for Volume 5, China absent from both lists. A link from the comic page to the three files, or re-hosting them on 360dialogues, moves them out of the orphan regime.

LinkedIn: from reactions to impressions, and the click gap

LinkedIn shows impressions to nobody but the author, so every conversion is a vendor’s sample of its own users. The launch-week post, by a bank economist with about 79,000 followers, shows 890 reactions and 104 comments. The clicks it implies at benchmark rates do not add up to the 26,823 measured visitors, and that gap is the most useful finding in this channel.

The launch post, impressions994 visible engagements divided by the rate
All posting, impressions
Distinct people in the feedmembers per impression, less 10 to 20 percent recurring engagers
Clicks at benchmark rate
Measured visitors, 2022 M

Report corridor: the launch post 60,000 / 120,000 / 250,000 impressions; all posting 96,000 / 210,000 / 450,000 impressions and 20,000 / 80,000 / 240,000 distinct feed viewers; this page stops at the central values. Dark social, the sharing through messaging apps and email that leaves no referrer (69 to 84 percent of share events in vendor studies of 2014 to 2018; 100 percent of visits from WhatsApp, Slack and Discord logged as “direct” in a 2023 test), adds no readers here, because those visits are already inside the 26,823; it decides which branch of the fork is true. Three numbers settle it: the launch post’s analytics, my own post analytics, and the site’s referrer breakdown for June to August 2022.

Orders of magnitude: people exposed to the comic in some form

Three blocks that overlap in ways no source can net out: people who opened the comic on any page or file, people who saw it in a feed and did not click, and people who saw it in a room. The measured core is 26,823. Low and central cases only.

Page openers 50,000 / 75,000 (the page corridor plus translations plus English reproductions such as the IEMA guide, the last an assumption); feed viewers 20,000 / 80,000 less whatever share of page visitors came from LinkedIn, unknown; learners 4,000 / 75,000, some of whom also visited the page. The two largest uncounted blocks rest on the two rates nobody has measured: the click-through rate of a recommendation post and the adoption rate among downloaders. Both are cheap to measure.

The nineteen multipliers: origin, issue, cheapest replacement
#Multiplier, value usedOriginIssueCheapest replacementWho holds it
1Chapters per session, 9 / 5 / 1.5B: COUNTER reports of one university, 2019 to 2021other platforms, pre-2025 rulesthe metric behind “uses” and a title-level countTaylor & Francis
2Visits per person, 2.0 / 1.5 / 1.2B: randomised trial 2007; platform statistic 2016journals, pre-2017page views against uses as a proxyTaylor & Francis
3Readings per use, 0.5 / 1 / 2B, assumption: surveys and logs 2008, 2018era and disciplinenone; stated assumption
4Off-platform downloads, 1,500 / 5,000 / 20,000 (Vol 5)B, assumption: KU pilot 2016; OAPEN 2020small samplesIRUS title reportKnowledge Unlatched, OAPEN
5OA download and citation multiples, 7 to 14 and 1.1 to 2.4B: publisher studies 2017 to 2024publisher-producedcontext only
6Share of comic visitors who teach, 5 / 8 / 15%B: MIT OCW 2011; OER Hub 2013 to 2015portals, not a professional comicdownloader survey, question 1me, the illustrator, Saxion
7Use rate among educators, 16 / 35 / 60%B: OCW 2011; Cool Australia 2020; EngineeringUKK-12; one commissionedsurvey question 2; slide-deck downloads; permission requestsmy mailbox; the site
8People per use, 10 / 30 / 60B: UK and Australian class sizes; HE comics studiesno workshop data anywheresurvey question 3
9Repeat runs, 1 / 1.5 / 2B: Oak 2023/24; OCW 2011 intentK-12; intent, not behavioursurvey question 4
10Course use among identified institutions, 5 / 10 / 20%B: BC faculty 2016; Bay View 2023textbooks, not edited volumesinstitution-level usage tableTaylor & Francis
11Carried against merely hosted translations, 10 to 100 timesB: MIT OCW 20052005; mirrors confoundedper-file downloads; carriers’ analyticsSaxion, AG Rohstoffe, Rethink & React, ANCI
12Orphan-page traffic, 0 to 10 visits a monthB, vendor: Ahrefs 2023; Botify 2020vendor; not university platformsbusinessmodellab.nl analyticsSaxion Business Model Lab
13Language ceilings, DE 0.12, ES 0.12, FR 0.10, IT 0.06, ZH 0.06 of EnglishB: Wikipedia views 2015 to 2025 (Pew 2026)consumer ratiosdownloads per language fileme
14LinkedIn engagement rate, 1.7 / 0.85 / 0.4% for a viral postB, vendor: AuthoredUp 2025/26; RevBoss 2026self-selected tool userspost analyticsthe launch post’s author; me for my own posts
152022-era reach factor, 1.5 to 3 timesB: van der Blom 2025, relayedgated report, relays disagreeown 2022 against 2025 analyticsme
16Members reached per impression, 0.27 / 0.465 / 0.60B, vendor: AuthoredUp, 42,493 postsself-selected samplepost analyticsthe launch post’s author; me
17Indexed share of public posts, 10 to 30%B: one creator’s check 2022; vendor commentary 2024 to 2026anecdotallogged-in LinkedIn search for the comic URLany member
18Link click-through rate, 0.3 / 0.5 / 1.0%B, vendor: Growthrocks 2018, 2021; 32 poststiny sample, 2018post click counts; site referrers, June to August 2022the launch post’s author; me
19Private shares per visible share, 2 to 6 timesB, vendor: RadiumOne 2014, 2016; GetSocial 2018ad-tech; consumer; pre-2015 misattributionthe site’s “direct” share for the deep URLme

How this page was made

I am the series editor of Factor X. I made this page in October 2026 to see what the five volumes and the comic have reached, and I used Claude, Anthropic’s AI assistant, for most of the mechanical work. This is what each of us did.

What I supplied. The two Routledge author usage reports for Volumes 4 and 5 (October 2026), the one verified figure for the comic page (26,823 unique visitors in 2022, from the site’s own statistics), and the two questions: what do the counts mean, and what do they miss.

What Claude did, under my direction. It searched the open web for every public trace of the volumes and the comic: publisher pages, Crossref and Semantic Scholar records read through their public interfaces, LinkedIn posts visible without logging in, blogs, newsletters, library guides. It read the Routledge reports I provided. It collected the benchmark studies and graded each by origin and date. It wrote the conversion arithmetic, the two written reports with every source, and the code of this page.

What I did with the result. I chose the evidence grades, decided which cases to show (this public version stops at the central estimate on every lever), checked the arithmetic of the tables, and had the most load-bearing figures re-checked against their sources in a separate pass. The reading of the numbers is mine, and so are any errors.

What nobody did. No logged-in LinkedIn data, no download logs from the hosting platforms, no survey of the people who used the comic. Those three would replace most of the benchmarks on this page; the register above names who holds them.

Dates. Web counts observed on 21 October 2026, Routledge reports read on 29 October 2026, benchmarks collected on 29 October 2026. Counts move daily. The two written reports, “Factor X books and comic reach” and “Factor X reach beyond the counts”, are available from me.